Chapter 140: Chapter 140: Threads of Possibility
Jerusalem, November 14, 1180
A winter wind drifted through the narrow slits of the Hospitaller commandery, fluttering the corners of open scrolls and loose parchment like restless spirits. Gérard of Ridefort sat in the chamber usually reserved for quiet prayer, now converted to a sanctuary of inquiry. Stacked documents surrounded him—worn codices, transcribed testimonies, and treatises from physicians across Outremer, Byzantium, and even distant Salerno.
He dipped his pen into ink, marking the margins of a Syrian casebook with methodical precision. His black mantle had been thrown over a nearby stool, leaving him in his plain wool robe, sleeves rolled to the elbow. Despite the chilly air, sweat gathered at his brow—not from heat, but from the weight of what he was learning.
Before him lay a bound volume from the infirmary of Acre, dated ten years prior.
"Brother Mikhael, aged thirty-one, reported to have fathered a son while in early stages of the affliction. His wife, examined yearly for seven years, showed no signs of the disease. Child healthy. Family lived under mild quarantine, but by the eighth year, no further measures taken."
Gérard muttered, "Seven years... untouched."
He moved to the next entry.
"Case of Yaqoub the Fisher, of Tyre. Contracted leprosy at twenty-five. Wife bore him two daughters before his exile to the colony. Both daughters married without sign of disease. Wife died in childbirth—no lesions or symptoms noted."
The ink scratched quietly as he annotated the margin. Then he reached for another scroll, one sent from Antioch before the war. This one, translated from a Greek physician in Cilicia, had been cited often among Hospitaller scholars.
"Leprosy not spread by contact alone. Certain humors and dispositions make a man more susceptible. It is not a punishment of touch, but of nature—what lies within the blood or essence. Not every wife of a leper becomes afflicted. Not every child born to one inherits the disease."
Gérard leaned back, rubbing his temples. He had heard these cases before, whispered as cautionary tales or anomalies. But now, pieced together, they formed a pattern: while leprosy remained a feared scourge, its transmission was not as inevitable—or as simple—as once believed.
He reached for his own notes and began drafting a separate summary:
"Preliminary review of twenty-three recorded cases of marital unions involving lepers:
Of 23 wives, only 3 contracted symptoms within 10 years.
Of 41 children, none showed early signs.
In most instances, close contact was not sufficient for contagion.
Affliction seems to require predisposition, heredity unproven.
Conclusion: physical union does not guarantee transmission. Risk present, but less certain than feared."
He paused. The implications were vast.
If the king were to marry—and even father a child—there remained a chance that neither wife nor offspring would be afflicted. It was no certainty, but it was possible. The disease did not leap like fire from skin to skin. It crept slowly, by means not yet understood, and often only after prolonged exposure.
He whispered a prayer: "Lord, grant me wisdom, not boldness. Let not hope become recklessness."
Then he rose, gathering the scrolls into a leather binder. These findings could not be circulated—yet. But they might, in time, offer an argument before the court. Perhaps even before Rome.
Elsewhere in JerusalemTower of David Citadel
Balian of Ibelin sat alone at a narrow table in the scriptorium, surrounded by charters, family records, and royal genealogies. A clerk of the Latin Kingdom, young and red-eyed from lack of sleep, dutifully fetched volumes from the archive one by one, each bearing the crest of foreign courts.
Balian’s eyes lingered now on a scroll bearing the golden eagle of Sicily. It was brittle with age, but still legible. At its center was a name he’d underlined in ink three times:
Constance, daughter of Roger II of Sicily.Aunt to King William II.Unmarried.Born 1154.Of age: 26.
Balian whispered aloud, "Almost the same age as Baldwin."
He turned to a manuscript authored by a monk from Monte Cassino, recounting the internal tensions of the Sicilian court after King William’s coronation. Constance had long been kept cloistered—not as a nun, but unmarried, almost forgotten. Many claimed it was to prevent rival claimants to William’s throne, since she was next in line should he die childless.
And still, Balian thought, she lives unmarried, politically idle—yet noble, well-educated, of royal blood.
Most importantly: her dowry would be enormous.
He quickly jotted down notes:
Alliance with Sicily = fleet access, Mediterranean reach.
Dowry could include siege equipment, coin, grain, timber.
Pope Alexander III favors the Normans—could bless such a match.
William II likely to agree if Jerusalem offers Sicilian access to eastern ports (Tyre, Acre, Beirut).
Constance of same age as Baldwin—potentially fertile, but no known lovers or previous betrothals.
It was, Balian realized, the most promising political union available.
France was too embroiled in its own court rivalries. England was at odds with the Angevins. The Empire had eyes on Italy. Hungary was too far. Byzantium remained wary, despite recent thawing. But Sicily—Sicily had blood ties to Outremer, fought in past crusades, and yearned for prestige.
He laid down his pen and rubbed his jaw.
Of course, no one could act on this openly. If the court suspected a change in succession was being planned, the lords might splinter. Baldwin’s nephew remained heir, and many barons—especially those once loyal to Raymond of Tripoli—would view such a shift as manipulation.
But Baldwin had no declared heir beyond the boy. And Baldwin could marry. It was not prohibited by canon law, even for a leper. Risky, yes. Scandalous, perhaps. But not impossible.
Late AfternoonHospitaller Compound
Gérard and Balian met at sunset near the Hospitaller garden, walking side by side along a gravel path surrounded by rosemary and olive trees. The cool air carried the scent of burning oil lamps from nearby chapels.
"I’ve found what we feared—and hoped," Gérard said quietly, holding out a scroll. "Evidence that many lepers have fathered children. And most did not pass on the disease. Nor did their wives contract it."
Balian took the scroll, scanning the summary. "You’re certain?"
"As certain as I can be. There are too many cases to dismiss them as flukes."
Balian nodded slowly. "Then the possibility of marriage becomes real. No longer a dream."
"It becomes a risk, but a measured one."
Gérard glanced over. "And what of your own search?"
Balian handed him his notes. "Constance of Sicily. Royal by birth. The only Norman princess of age and unmarried. She’s hidden in a convent, but not a nun. Her nephew, King William, guards her jealously—but with the right terms, he might release her for a high alliance."
Gérard studied the parchment. "And the Pope?"
"He favors the Sicilians. If Jerusalem offered them eastern ports, or other terms, we could secure a Queen."
Both men stood in silence.
The bells of the Holy Sepulchre began to toll in the distance. Gérard spoke first.
"This must remain between us and the king for now."
"Agreed," Balian said.
"And if the king presses forward?"
Balian glanced skyward. "Then we must pray God guides him—both for the realm, and for the child he may one day bring into it."
They turned back toward the palace together, carrying with them the weight of possibility—not certainty, not yet—but the fragile architecture of a future that could be built if wisdom, health, and time allowed.